Please disable your Ad Blocker to better interact with this website.

Government PoliciesNews

Amending the First Amendment

By Logan Albright/

Slowly making its way through the Senate without too much notice is a joint resolution (S.J.Res. 19), sponsored by Tom Udall and enjoying the vocal support of Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, that would rewrite the founding document of our country in ways never before imagined.

The bill is short, only one page, but the few words printed there are devastating. Udall’s resolution proposes an amendment to the U.S. Constitution that would give Congress the authority to regulate political speech, in direct contradiction to the First Amendment.

Despite the fact that Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that spending on political campaigns is classified as protected speech, Democrats in Congress continue to regard money in politics as a great threat to our Democracy—at least when it comes from individuals and non-profit groups rather than labor unions and lobbyists.

Still, this bill goes farther than previous efforts to restrict spending, in that it does not target only direct campaign contributions. Section 1 of the resolution authorizes Congress to place limits on “the amount of funds that may be spent by, in support of, or in opposition to” political candidates.

The phrases “in support of” or “in opposition to” are incredibly broad, however, and can be taken to mean almost anything. It is entirely conceivable that books and movies discussing candidates and their positions could fall under this statute. It is chilling, and entirely contrary to the American ethos, that government could be able to censor books and films containing political content.

In an apparent attempt to mitigate criticism of the bill’s language, Section 3 specifies, “Nothing in this article shall be construed to grant Congress the power to abridge the freedom of the press.” The obvious question here is: what constitutes “the press”?

In the context of the First Amendment, this disclaimer is unacceptably narrow, especially since the vast majority of traditional journalists are registered Democrats. It is clear that the proposed amendment is nothing more than an attempt to disproportionately silence conservative speech.

Additionally, the very necessity of including such an exception shows how broad the amendment’s powers would be. Exempting the press means that everything other than the press is fair game.

Fortunately, the framers of the Constitution were sufficiently wise to anticipate these sorts of problems, and thus required an extremely rigorous consensus for the amendment process. Proposed amendments much obtain a two-thirds majority vote in both chambers of Congress, followed by a three-quarters majority of state legislatures.

This requirement means that there is exactly zero chance of Udall’s bill ever becoming law. It is a symbolic act only, and there is no need for free speech advocates to panic—at least not yet.

Still, the fact that such an amendment would even be proposed, much less be able to garner support from 48 Senate cosponsors (46 Democrats and 2 independents) is extremely troubling.

The following Senators have signed on as cosponsors to the resolution, and the phone numbers of their offices:

Sen. Baldwin, Tammy [D-WI] (202) 224-5653
Sen. Begich, Mark [D-AK] (202) 224-3004
Sen. Bennet, Michael F. [D-CO] (202) 224-5852
Sen. Blumenthal, Richard [D-CT] (202) 224-2823
Sen. Booker, Cory A. [D-NJ] (202) 224-3224
Sen. Boxer, Barbara [D-CA] (202) 224-3553
Sen. Brown, Sherrod [D-OH] (202) 224-2315
Sen. Cantwell, Maria [D-WA)
Sen. Cardin, Benjamin L. [D-MD] (202) 224-4524
Sen. Carper, Thomas R. [D-DE] (202) 224-2441
Sen. Casey, Robert [D-PA] Sen. Coons, Christopher A. [D-DE] (202) 224-5042
Sen. Durbin, Richard [D-IL] (202) 224-2152
Sen. Feinstein, Dianne [D-CA] (202) 224-3841
Sen. Franken, Al [D-MN] (202) 224-5641
Sen. Gillibrand, Kirsten E. [D-NY] (202) 224-4451
Sen. Hagan, Kay [D-NC] (202) 224-6342
Sen. Harkin, Tom [D-IA] (202) 224-3254
Sen. Heinrich, Martin [D-NM] (202) 224-5521
Sen. Heitkamp, Heidi [D-ND] (202) 224-2043
Sen. Hirono, Mazie K. [D-HI] (202) 224-6361
Sen. Johnson, Tim [D-SD] (202) 224-5842
Sen. King, Angus S. Jr. [I-ME] (202) 224-5344
Sen. Klobuchar, Amy [D-MN] (202) 224-3244
Sen. Levin, Carl [D-MI] Sen. Manchin, Joe, III [D-WV] (202) 224-3954
Sen. Markey, Edward J. [D-MA] (202) 224-2742
Sen. McCaskill, Claire [D-MO] Sen. Menendez, Robert [D-NJ] (202) 224-4744
Sen. Merkley, Jeff [D-OR] (202) 224-3753
Sen. Mikulski, Barbara A. [D-MD] (202) 224-4654
Sen. Murphy, Christopher S. [D-CT] (202) 224-4041
Sen. Murray, Patty [D-WA] (202) 224-2621
Sen. Nelson, Bill [D-FL] Sen. Reed, Jack [D-RI] (202) 224-4642
Sen. Reid, Harry [D-NV] (202) 224-3542
Sen. Rockefeller, John D., IV [D-WV] (202) 224-6472
Sen. Sanders, Bernard [I-VT] (202) 224-5141
Sen. Schatz, Brian [D-HI] (202) 224-3934
Sen. Schumer, Charles E. [D-NY] (202) 224-6542
Sen. Shaheen, Jeanne [D-NH] (202) 224-2841
Sen. Stabenow, Debbie [D-MI] (202) 224-4822
Sen. Tester, Jon [D-MT] (202) 224-2644
Sen. Udall, Mark [D-CO] (202) 224-5941
Sen. Walsh, John E. [D-MT] (202) 224-2651
Sen. Warren, Elizabeth [D-MA] (202) 224-4543
Sen. Whitehouse, Sheldon [D-RI] (202) 224-2921
Sen. Wyden, Ron [D-OR] (202) 224-5244

Originally posted at

Deneen Borelli

Deneen Borelli is the author of Blacklash: How Obama and the Left are Driving Americans to the Government Plantation. Deneen is a contributor with Newsmax Broadcasting. She is a former Fox News contributor and has appeared regularly on “Hannity,” “Fox & Friends,” “Your World with Neil Cavuto,” and “America’s Newsroom.” She has also appeared on Fox Business Network programs “Making Money with Charles Payne,” “The Evening Edit with Liz MacDonald,” and “Cavuto: Coast to Coast.” Previously, Deneen appeared on MSNBC, CNN, the BBC and C-SPAN. In addition to television, Deneen co-hosted radio programs on the SiriusXM Patriot channel with her husband Tom. Recently, Deneen co-hosted the Reigniting Liberty podcast with Tom. Deneen is a frequent speaker at political events, including the FreedomWorks 9.12.2009 March on D.C. which drew a crowd estimated at over 800,000 people. Deneen is also an Ambassador with, a social media platform that promotes free speech, and with the America First Policy Institute (AFPI) which advances policies that put Americans first. Deneen testified before the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Natural Resources in May 2011 and before the Ohio House Public Utilities Committee in December 2011. Previously, Deneen was a host, Outreach Director with overseeing its outreach program, a Project 21 Senior Fellow, and Manager of Media Relations with the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE). Prior to joining CORE, Deneen worked at Philip Morris USA for 20 years. During her corporate career at Philip Morris she worked in various positions, her last as Project Management Coordinator in the Information Management department where she was responsible for the department’s mandated quality processes, communications, sales information and database management. Deneen began her Philip Morris career as a secretary and advanced to positions of increasing responsibilities. Deneen worked full-time and attended classes at night for 11 years to earn her B.A. in Managerial Marketing from Pace University, New York City. Deneen served on the Board of Trustees with The Opportunity Charter School in Harlem, New York. She appeared in educational videos for children, worked as a runway fashion model, and auditioned for television commercials. Her interests include ancient history, pistol target shooting, photography, and volunteering at her church. Deneen currently resides in Connecticut with her husband Tom.

Related Articles